Breadcrumb

  • Home
  • Imaginary Friends 1 - Yes, No, Maybe





Amazon Prime Trial

Search form

Main navigation

  • Home

HOME | ALL TECHNOLOGY

Imaginary Friends 1 - Yes, No, Maybe

Wednesday, 5 March, 2025 - 11:45

″Artificial Intelligence is neither artificial or intelligent″ - Professor Ian Angell, London University, c. 2000. 

Discuss. 

Taking a quarter of a century old statement by one of the world's leading Professors in Information Systems as a starting point, four imaginary friends discuss the fundamental issues of whether "artificial intelligence" is an artificial construct.

A: Computers are dumb. Computers recognise only two states: on and off, one or zero, black or white. 

B: If that’s the case, how do we get yes, no or maybe : that’s the basis of fuzzy logic that has become a topic du jour now that FinCEN has announced it’s going to use it.

C: Fuzzy logic was first described in a paper in the 1970s. By the 1980s we had it in toasters and washing machines. FinCEN is behind the times.

A: Is fuzzy logic a state? 

C: Well, it’s not on or off so if it’s a state, it’s a third state.

B: I don’t think it’s a single state. I think it’s just nested states. Like those Russian Dolls. Each of them is on or off, doll or not doll. But maybe it’s also parallel decision making. So it’s looking in more than one set of dolls at the same time and using the information from all of them to reach a decision.

A: Like this: is the toast burned yet? Is the toast burned yet? Is the toast burned yet? Oh, bugger. It’s burned. 

C: Well, yes. But it still needs a human to decide how thick and how dry the bread is and how brown he wants his toast. Then he sets the instruction and leaves the toaster to act as instructed. When the circumstances are right, i.e. the bread is toasted as instructed, it then pops up.

A: So it’s not thinking, is it?

B: No, it’s not thinking at all but it is doing more than ones and zeros.

A: But is it? Is it ready? No. Continue. Is it ready? No. Continue. Is it ready? Yes, pop up. It’s still if-then-else algorithms. 

C: So the conclusion is that even fuzzy logic depends on the parameters and instructions it’s given. 

A: More than that: it depends on the data it has and in this case the data – is the bread toasted enough? – doesn’t come from the human: it comes from a sensor. And it collects and acts on that without human intervention.

B: So it is acting autonomously? Doesn’t that mean it’s thinking?

A: It’s acting autonomously in the sense that a golf ball is autonomous when it’s sitting on the tee waiting to be hit. The sensor gathers data and passes it to the processor. For want of a better phrase, that’s an unthinking activity. There is no intelligence involved. And there is no intelligence in the processor: it receives data, it does a yes/no assessment and either does nothing (i.e. continues toasting) or activates the pop up (i.e. stops toasting). The ″maybe″ element is because it loops the question back and reassesses it with new data from the sensor until it pops up. 

B: Golf ball?

A: It sits, waiting for input. If it doesn’t get any, it continues waiting. 

C: What about machine learning?

A: What about it? It’s still not autonomous. It does what it’s told to do. We know what happens if the parameters are not set: it continues to do what it’s been told until someone unplugs it. Like the Facebook system that developed a coded language that its operators did not understand. But while it was off and running without constraint, it was still acting within its instructions. So we can say that instructions are not the same as parameters.

Machine learning is not clever. It’s simply an advanced filing system with analytical processes that draw inferences from disparate sources in ways it’s been told to do. The execution requires humans of considerable ability, that’s where ″clever″ and ″intelligent″ comes in but what the machine does is basic. 

C: Can machines think like humans? 

D: Aha, I know the answer to that. Machines cannot think because they have no intellectual capacity. They cannot feel, because they have no emotional capacity. But they can be programmed to fake it. Machines can be fitted with sensors that can gather data and analyse it as required. But it’s just the same as a psychopath: ″I see someone cry so I know I’m supposed to seem sympathetic. But I’m not actually sympathetic″.

A: So, we agree with the old statement from Ian Angell, even though there have been many developments since?

C: Do we agree with Alan Turing in 1950 when he said there is a common view that ″thinking is a function of man's immortal soul. God has given an immortal soul to every man and woman, but not to any other animal or to machines. Hence no animal or machine can think. I am unable to accept any part of this.″ 

He went on – and in this statement we can see the genesis of the entire Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning worlds - ″It can also be maintained that it is best to provide the machine with the best sense organs that money can buy and then teach it to understand and speak English. This process could follow the normal teaching of a child. Things would be pointed out and named, etc. Again I do not know what the right answer is, but I think both approaches should be tried.″

So he took the view that machines don’t think but only act upon what they have been taught but he wished that machines might be able to think and encouraged further research. 

A: Aha, the Cambridge philosophers of the early 1900s most of whom were mathematicians. 

D: Precisely so. Even Turing quotes Bertrand Russell but he was quite a late arrival on a well established scene. Their idea was that language was at the root of everything because without it one could describe nothing. Or rather, one could not describe anything. Those two sentences demonstrate an irony: today, computers require precision in language, punctuation and grammar but humans seem hell bent on removing precision. It was because of Turing’s approach that, in the 1980s, there was such competition to produce machines that could type from audio. They were rubbish and even now they are not very good. 

C: Ah, the ″impacts″ argument that a) something should impact ″upon″ something else and b) mostly the word ″impact″ is used because the person using it is too lazy to decide whether to use ″effect″ or ″affect.″

A: Yes. And ″I could care less″ which says exactly the opposite of what it means and the confusion over ″protests″ v ″protests against″ and, of course, billion v milliard. Defence v defense. I once read, in a novel, the expression ″athletic pants.″ If we want computers to understand words and phrases, we have to teach them not only languages and dialects but changes which run riot in some sectors of society but have no effect in others.

How is the computer supposed to know?

C: Aha! You just imputed a human function to a computer: you said it could ″know.″ That feeds into Knowledge, Belief and Suspicion which are fundamental in e.g. financial services with regard to financial crime. So are you admitting that it is capable of one of those things in which case, because they are all part of a continuum , means it must also be capable of the others.

A: er, sloppy use of language. In that context, it does not know. But it does hold information which it can access and, if it looks at other information it holds, it can decide, if it has been properly programmed, whether that information is subject to challenge or not subject to challenge. But no, it’s not knowledge or belief. ″Knowing″ something in the context of being in possession of information is not the same as ″Knowing it to be true.″ 

Furthermore, if it reaches the decision that the information is subject to question, does that automatically mean that the machine is suspicious?

I think not: even if it were human, simply being uncertain of something is not the same as being suspicious of it.

D: Conclusions? I’ll start : Turing was quite an Old Testament kind of chap but he was pretty ambivalent about religions. Ultimately, if one analyses his state of mind from e.g. COMPUTING MACHINERY AND INTELLIGENCE, he wants to believe in thinking machines and he hopes they will appear in the future, but he thinks machines can do no more than imitate humans, and then only if humans tell them what to do. He also says the the quality of data is paramount if computers are to produce worthwhile results.

A: I’m completely with Ian Angell. Yes, no, maybe. Nothing else. 

B: Or even yes, no, now what?

C: I accept the filing cabinets of the mind theory and that data found there can be cross-referenced and conclusions drawn. But I’m a long way from accepting that computers can handle unknown unknowns and, even, that they don’t know what they don’t know. 

Then again, to undermine my own argument, computers work out where Black Holes are and those are unknown unknowns that are imputed from surrounding data not from the data itself. So I am changing my mind as I speak: computers can identify that there is an unknown unknown, so converting it to a known unknown. But what’s in the hole remains unknown so they still don’t know what they don’t know even though they know they don’t know something. 


I think that’s in the general direction of intelligence if it knows that there is something that should be investigated be it in space or in internal corporate data. 

But no, the over-riding position is that computers identify black holes only because they have been told to identify vacancies where the programming says there should be data. It’s just an exception report. 

B: I get the psychopath reference and I cannot see, with the present state of development, any realistic chance of an empathetic computer even though I can see that it can fake it from data that it captures. 


 

---------------------------------


https://academic.oup.com/mind/article/LIX/236/433/986238#164226500

 

FinCEN: the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, a division of the US Department of the Treasury that receives reports from a wide range of businesses relating to transactions exceeding certain limits and where there is suspicion that funds may be related to certain criminal conduct. 

 

NB: we must spell out Machine Learning in full every time for the simple reason that in financial services ML always, always, always means ″money laundering.″ 

An edited version of this article was published at the-yuan.com June 2022

Imaginary Friends 1 - Yes, No, Maybe 

Imaginary Friends 2 - Of Cogs and Golfballs 

Imaginary Friends 3: ″Capital Punishment? 

Imaginary Friends 4 - An Uncommon Language 

Imaginary Friends 5 - ″The first thing we do, let's kill all the lawyers" 

Imaginary Friends: 6. The circles of an imaginary mind…...

About this section

From FinTech to RegTech, from "AI" to security, from the terraverse to the metaverse, if there's a technology element, we're interested. But this is not an area for PR. It's an area for considered, structured articles that advance arguments. Think Op-Ed with a purpose.

Opinion pieces or "Op-Eds" are the home-made bombs of the publishing world. So long as they meet editorial standards, are not intentionally offensive with a view to causing hurt or insult and are relevant to our field of endeavour, we will look at submissions.

We like contentious, we like contrarian views. We don't like pretty much any -ism . We recognise that Opinion pieces are one person's view and are not balanced (if they are balanced and reach a reasoned conclusion, they are probably more suited to the Articles section). We do not like empty expressions (reaching out, going forward, circling back etc), acronyms and buzzwords. English, only please.

To submit an Opinion / Technology piece, please complete the Contact form.

Footer menu

  • Weekly Digest (opens in new tab)
  • Images attribution (opens in new tab)
  • Corporate, privacy, intellectual property and access (opens in new tab)
  • Advertising and Recommendations (opens in new tab)
  • Promote your business (opens in new tab)
  • Enquiries (opens in new tab)


 

BOT AND SCRAPER ACCESS DENIED

 


 

Built with Drupal     |     Hosted by Siteground     |     Template by Alaa Haddad     

Design by Vortex Centrum Limited    |     Some services provided by Google Workspace    

Posters and other merch by ProjectLXX   |   Privacy and security services by Surfshark and Firetrust. 


Nothing in this website is intended to be or shall be taken as legal advice. 

You should always seek advice from a practitioner experienced in this area. 


Everything on this website is copyright Nigel Morris-Cotterill and/or Vortex Centrum Limited for itself or one of its business units. No downloading, printing or other means of replicating or reusing is permitted. In particular, all bot access is denied and all scraping of content will result in the legal action set forth in the terms and conditions in this site. For legal, cookies and privacy see vortexcentrum.com.

Copyright 1999- © 2026 Vortex Centrum Limited - All rights reserved. Bot access denied.